Posted by: Lisa Hill | May 15, 2009

Vertigo (2008), by Amanda Lohrey

It doesn’t take long to read this novella – only an hour or so – but it certainly leaves an impact, especially so soon after the Victorian bushfires on Black Saturday.


Luke and Anna are thirtysomethings from Sydney who make a tree change, settling in the coastal hamlet of Garra Nalla.  There they leave behind the pressures of city life and mild envy of more successful friends with large mortgages and share portfolios to monitor.  They were relieved to be free of ‘dinner parties [where] people spoke solemnly of their renovations; with the air of diplomats renegotiating the Geneva Convention they discoursed on the problems of installing a second bathroom.’ (p8)

Lohrey deftly sketches the housing affordability crisis: these two work hard but they can’t afford Sydney and they can’t even do the bush on their own.  They need the help of both sets of parents to buy the old Federation house, affordable only because it lacks sea views.  They learn to love the simple things, like bird-watching; they plant a vegie patch.  They make friends and play tennis with friends on a simple backyard court, with nary a Nike to be seen. Here they discuss drought-proofing their properties with appropriate solemnity for it has barely rained for seven years and every drop is precious.  Two showers a week – that’s a very arresting image!

The ease of their lifestyle compared to the stress of city life is offset by this fear of the drought, the hard physical labour of planting, and the asymmetrical patterns of their sleep.  She’s a night owl, wedded to CNN; he sleeps soundly and easily at night.  And both of them see the boy. Lohrey handles this little apparition with great sensitivity.  It is not until the end of the novella that we learn why they see this child flitting in and out of their lives:

…to their great delight, on each of these journeys, the boy chose to accompany them.  In the claustrophobic spaces of their apartment his appearances were erratic and unpredictable, but once out on the freeway they would glance behind them and there he would be, lap-sashed on the back seat, and with an enquiring look on his face; that dreamy, expectant expression that children get when they are travelling to an unknown destination. (p10)

The bushfire, when it comes, is as savage and unpredictable as we have all now learned to fear. Lohrey shows without scorn the complacency of the locals who declare that the fires ‘never reach the coast’ (p92) and the belated preparations of the tree changers.  Luke and Anna discover too late that their pumps won’t work if the electricity fails, and they don’t clear a firebreak until the fire is almost upon them.  Experience and inexperience alike fail when drought and wind conspire as they never have before to create a conflagration that behaves in uncharacteristic ways.

It’s too easy to be wise after the event.  Knowing about radiant heat and ember attacks is one thing; being psychologically able to deal with them is another and there are many who overestimate their ability to confront fire in all its raw and capricious power.  Everyone knows that you shouldn’t try to flee a fire at the last minute, but who can foretell panic?

Lohrey’s last book, The Philosopher’s Doll, was about the ethical issues confronting couples with dissimilar desires about parenthood.  In Vertigo her characters share a loss and deal with it in different but complementary ways.  There is a sense of great love between these two and the reader closes this slim book with hope for them both.

BTW I found a most intriguing review on a website devoted to W.G. Sebald, which makes explicit some ‘Sebaldian’ touches, and TasPhoto has some interesting asides about the thumbnail photos by Lorraine Biggs.  I would have liked these photos granted a whole page, but perhaps the publisher had to keep within a certain number of pages to keep printing costs down.

Vertigo: A Novella Author: Amanda Lohrey
Title:Vertigo: A Novella
Publisher: Black Inc 2009
ISBN: 1863954309
Source: Kingston Library

Fishpond: Vertigo: A Novella


  1. […] have previously reviewed her short story collection Reading Madame Bovary and her stunning novella Vertigo but a new novel has been a long time coming … her last one was The Philosopher’s Doll in 2004, […]


  2. […] Amanda Lohrey is an author whose career I’ve been following ever since I first discovered her writing, way back in 1997 when she co-authored Secrets with Robert Dessaix and Drusilla Modjeska.  I started with The Philosopher’s Doll (2004), which was before I started this blog (but see this perceptive review by Aviva Tuffield at The Age).  Exploring issues or work-life balance and the Generation X biological clock dilemma, The Philosopher’s Doll was long-listed for the 2005 Miles Franklin and for the IMPAC in 2006, and I promptly added Lohrey to my list of must-read authors.  Subsequent to that I read Camille’s Bread which was shortlisted for the Miles Franklin in 1996 and won the Australian Literature Society’s Gold Medal in the same year.  (See a review by Troy Martin at Lit-is-Stan), and then there was her stunning novella Vertigo – which is my favourite, and you can read my enthusiastic review here. […]


  3. […] about an arsonist, The Slap (Lisa’s review), Amanda Lohrey’s 2009 novella Vertigo (Lisa’s review), and Lexi Landsman’s 2016 novel The ties that bind (Lisa’s […]


  4. […] and most recently A Short History of Richard Kline (2015).  But my favourite of them all is Vertigo from 2008. Very few writers have written about bushfire so compellingly, though Tassie-born Karenlee […]


  5. […] (1995), and The Philosopher’s Doll (2004), and reviewed here on the blog, I’ve read Vertigo (2008), Reading Madame Bovary (2010), and The Short History of Richard Kline (2015).  But I had […]


  6. […] small coastal town of Garra Nalla which featured in her novella Vertigo (2008, see my thoughts here).  But unlike Vertigo‘s young couple swapping high house prices in Sydney for what they […]


Please share your thoughts and join the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: