Posted by: Lisa Hill | November 3, 2014

Melbourne Dreaming (1997, new edition 2014), by Meyer Eidelson

Melbourne DreamingI have had a wonderful day today, thanks to this exciting new edition of Melbourne Dreaming, A Guide to Important Places of the Past and Present.

It is, as the name implies, a guide to the indigenous heritage of our city.  First published in 1997 but now updated, the guide lists 36 places of interest, grouped by location so that exploring can be done in manageable chunks.

In the city, you can discover the Freedom Fighters execution site on the corner of Bowen and Franklin Streets where Maulboyheenner and Tunnerminnerwait became the first men executed in Victoria.  They were not allowed to give evidence in their defence because they were deemed unable to take the Christian oath and although the jury recommended leniency on the grounds of general good character and the peculiar circumstances in which they are placed’ the government was determined to make an example of them and they were executed on January 20th, 1842.   You can visit the Koorie Heritage Centre which houses one of the largest indigenous collections in the country including 10,000 weavings, baskets, eel traps, paintings and other artefacts.  There’s the Bujilaka Cultural Centre, the Birrarung (Yarra) art and Heritage Walk, Billibellary’s Walk, the scarred tree in the Fitzroy Gardens, and more.  You have to get the book to see just how rich this heritage is in the CBD, a modern bustling city with an ancient history that is unique in the world.

Further out in the eastern suburbs, there’s the Stonnington Indigenous History Trail, the Bolin Bolin Billabong, and another scarred tree at the Heidi Museum. (How many times have I been to Heidi and not known this?!)  There are astonishing earth rings at Sunbury in the outer north, and a fish trap at Solomon’s Ford in the west.  Down on the Mornington Peninsula (where there are numerous congenial wineries for sustenance en route) there is Collins’ Settlement and Bunjil’s Cave.

Fascinated by the wealth of things to investigate, I decided to start in my own area.  I set out today with my friend Mairi Neil (occasional guest reviewer on this blog) to walk some of the Bayside Coastal Trail.   We parked the car at Middle Brighton – where we discovered that the book is a tad misleading here and there: the Barraimal Emu is actually about a 20 minute walk back towards Elwood from the Middle Brighton Pier – which wouldn’t have mattered if we had started from Elwood as suggested, but did confuse us a little until we found the coastal trail guide panel by the pier and worked out which way to go.   But the walk was worth it: we were fascinated by the story of the emu (which you can see on the panels on the slide show) and delighted by the sculpture depicting the Barraimal Constellation, an emu’s body, nest and eggs created by the Southern Cross, Pointer, Scorpio, Sagittarius and Coalsack Nebula in our southern skies.  (It’s one thing to read about this in reference books, as I have, when planning a unit on Space for school, and another thing entirely to see it represented as a work of art in this way.  BTW this constellation is only visible in the night sky in June, July and August, see here).

One thing we discovered quite quickly is that covering this entire trail might be quite expensive for some visitors.   Bayside Council charges an astonishing $5.00 per hour even for street parking along the Beach Rd, and the full trail would involve parking the car half a dozen times in different places.   For the energetic a bike is probably the best solution.  Not an option for me with my dodgy ankle…

My dodgy ankle also meant that traipsing across the sand at Dendy Street was out.  Fortunately Mairi is an excellent photographer and it’s her picture of the midden that you can see in the slideshow.  It’s astonishing to find this precious reminder of former indigenous cooking fires on a suburban beach in our city.  But there it is, one kilometre long in the natural dune system.  The book tells me that there are more than 350 of these middens recorded around Port Phillip Bay.

Brighton was one of the most popular fishing places for the Boom Wurrung in Melbourne before two miles (3.2 kilometres) of the Brighton foreshore was sold to Henry Dendy in 1841.  Dendy Street beach was an ideal willam [camp]. Sand dunes provided natural shelter from the wind and sun and a soft place for sitting.  Native trees provided firewood and shelters.  Most importantly there is a very large shallow reef adjoining the beach.  Reefs are good sources of shellfish and crustaceans.  These in turn attract fish which could be speared.  Stone traps could be built on reefs using the tide to strand fish.  Stone from the reef could be used to sharpen tools or provide rocks to increase the heat of fires.

At Brighton, Kulin women in particular harvested shellfish and many of the plants found on the coast such as Karawun (Mat Rush), Kummeree (Pigface), Worike (Banksia), Bowat (Poa Grass), Kabin (Running Postman) and Seaberry.  (p.114)

We think that clearer directions might have been useful in some places – we never did find the panels on the Beach Road opposite Sims Street in Sandringham, but we consoled ourselves with a very pleasant lunch at Coffee  Cottage and it was such a glorious day that we didn’t mind.  And what’s more, even without the promised signage to guide us, we had begun to perceive our landscape in an entirely different way.  I have walked these pathways by the beach hundreds of times without knowing its story, now I know better, thanks to this book. By the time I dropped Mairi back home and slipped round to the Mordialloc Aboriginal Reserve to see the scarred trees I had begun to feel – as I did in Pompeii – that there was a living history beneath my feet and a presence that demanded my respect.

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

I am delighted to be able to share this experience with a giveaway copy of Melbourne Dreaming, thanks to Aboriginal Studies Press and Scott Eathorne from Quikmark Media. The usual rules apply:

All entries from readers with an Australian postcode will be eligible but it is a condition of entry that if you are the winner, you must contact me with a postal address by the deadline that will be specified in the blog post that announces the winner. (I’ll redraw if this deadline isn’t met). Please note that your address will be passed on to the publisher who will send you the book direct.

Please indicate your interest in the Comments box below and I’ll select a winner using a random generator by the middle of November.

Good luck!

Author: Meyer Eidelson
Title:Melbourne Dreaming, A Guide to Important Places of the Past and Present (2nd edition)
Publisher: Aboriginal Studies Press, 2014, first published 1997)
ISBN: 9781922059710
Source: Review copy courtesy of Aboriginal Studies Press and Scott Eathorne from Quikmark Media.


Fishpond: Melbourne Dreaming: A Guide to Important Sites of the Past and Present


  1. I would love a copy of this book. I come to Melbourne often and it would be a good guide to this beautiful city.


  2. Melbourne Dreaming sounds fascinating, I would love to win a copy


  3. What a joyous review Lisa. Thank you so much for the slideshow. It is not often that one gets to test out a book’s worthiness ‘on foot’. Melbourne Dreaming sounds delightful so please count me in.


  4. Melbourne Dreaming would be a great read and walk. I love books like this that put you in the times of bygone years. I also enjoy books that write about places that you are familiar with; nothing like thinking “I remember now”. I would love to win the book. I don’t think I will drive to Brighton, but I will take the train and then go on foot. Thanks for the slide show.



  5. Good luck, Margaret, Moira, Karenlee and Meg – you are in the draw:)


  6. 2015 is going to be my year of indigenous reading, so I’d love to go in the draw.


  7. I would love to win a copy of this book so please include me in the draw but, if I don’t win, I’ll buy a copy anyway. I wish there were similar initiatives covering the whole state (and indeed, the whole country). Thanks so much for reviewing this.


  8. OK, Jane and MST, you are in! Good luck:)


  9. Very interesting – Melbourne has far more historic sites than I thought possible. I loved the photographs which make it all look very appealing.


    • Ah yes, Sydney claims the harbour, but we here in Melbourne have the much more accessible Port Phillip Bay, and I live 3 minutes away from it by car, or a 30 minute walk. It’s beautiful in all weathers, but my favourite time is in the early morning in summer when it is a sublime shade of pale blue misting into the horizon, or when it’s a steely grey in winter and you need to rug up for a brisk walk along the coastal paths.


  10. Yes please I would love to win this book as I have Aboriginal family I would find it realy interesting to read. Thanks


  11. Wow! I have soooo much to learn about our heritage. I would love to read (and learn) more. This review has just whetted my appetite. Please enter me in the draw to win this fabulous book.


  12. Good luck Cristina and Valmai:)


  13. This book sounds fascinating


  14. What a valuable book! I used to live down Brighton way and had no idea about the Aboriginal heritage of the area. Does the book have any maps? (It doesn’t sound like it)


    • Yes, it does have maps. Our problem was that we took a linear pathway over quite a long distance and so while the map shows the sites between Elwood and Mordialloc, it’s impossible for them to show enough detail over that distance. But for the city walks, e.g. the Fitzroy Aboriginal heritage trail, the distance is much more compact and the map seems to show very clearly where everything is. I have plans to do more of these walks next Spring when the weather is so nice for walking:)


  15. Reblogged this on deansmithdancingbear.


  16. […] I’ve hovered over Welcome to Country, a Travel Guide to Indigenous Australia a couple of times in bookshops, but decided against buying it.  I think it’s a perfect book for international visitors, or for backpackers and grey nomads travelling around Australia, but I’m more interested in my local Melbourne history than this book has space to offer.  My Go-To book for the 60,000 year old story of Indigenous Melbourne is Meyer Eidelson’s Melbourne Dreaming (2014), published by the Aboriginal Studies Press, because it features lots of wonderful walks around my city.  You can see my adventures on the Bayside trail in my review. […]


Please share your thoughts and join the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: