Posted by: Lisa Hill | September 8, 2015

After This (2015), by Alice Nelson

After ThisIn view of the refugee crisis in Europe, it seems apposite to be reading this collection of testaments from survivors of the Holocaust, people who fled Europe to make a new life here in Australia.  With a foreword by Arnold Zable and a powerful introductory essay by Alice Nelson, the book consists of fourteen narratives which consist of what Zable calls a three-act drama: the time before, when there was home, family and a sense of belonging; a period of unrelenting horrors; and then liberation, accompanied by a sense of devastation, loss, a period in limbo and then rebuilding a life…

Reading these stories is an emotional experience.  No matter how much you think you know about the Holocaust, the personal story brings to the fore the very ordinariness of people who are just like us, who went through the unimaginable.  The B&W photos make this ordinariness vivid  – pictures of little kids; a girl who perished with her doll; a brother and sister who died in Sobibor – because a labourer had a fight with the farmer who was hiding them and got his revenge by giving them away to the Nazis.  And yet remarkably these people came here to the other side of the world, with nothing in their pockets, and somehow managed to create new lives, new families, new reasons to go on living.  The family photos taken in Australia are a testament to the human spirit and what can be achieved when people are given a fair go.

This year is the 70th anniversary of the liberation of the camps, but this anniversary has a special resonance because so many of those who were freed have since died.  There are few survivors left to bear witness now.  So many of the stories in this book conclude with a shift from the first person narrative to the author’s gentle summary that this survivor has now passed on.  One especially poignant summary concludes with the postscript Not much is known about Aaron’s life in Australia and the whereabouts of his descendants.  (p. 145, following the story of Aaron Landau).  It seems dreadfully sad that after so much loss, family connections are again broken, so if anyone reading this knows Danielle Landau, his daughter or any of Aaron Landau’s descendants, do connect with Alice Nelson or the Holocaust Museum of WA.

What is particularly striking in the context of the European refugee crisis, is that although anti-Semitism was the soil which allowed Nazism to flourish, there were many ordinary people who helped to rescue Jews from the murderous Germans.  Farmers, pharmacists, teachers and Christian pastors found hiding places and extra rations, while a miraculous chain of underground heroes moved Jews from place to place, often just a few steps ahead of certain death.  Today, it is not necessary to risk your life to try to help the flood of refugees in Europe and the camps in the Middle East: all that’s needed is to open your heart, speak up, and try to persuade others to do the same – so that once again we can see the efforts of ordinary people to bring their political leaders to show humanity in the face of human misery on a scale not seen since the end of the war.

Let’s hope those efforts do not fall on deaf ears in Australia.

PS (the next day)

If you would like to help the present refugees either in Europe or in the camps in the Middle East which this week had to cut back on food rations because they are overwhelmed by numbers, this article in The Age includes a useful summary of agencies that are working in the field.   They keep updating the article, so you may need to scroll down to find the list.

Author: Alice Nelson
Title: After This: Survivors of the Holocaust speak
Publisher: Fremantle Press, 2015
ISBN: 9781925162356
Review copy courtesy of Fremantle Press

Fishpond: After This: Survivors of the Holocaust Speak (eBook also available)



  1. Thank you for a moving review. I’ve just been given the book but haven’t read it yet. My parents were Holocaust survivors; my husband was born before the war ended and his parents was hidden by a Dutch family. We need to keep believing that most humans are good people.


    • Hello Anna, I guess this book will be immeasurably emotional for you. It’s not a book you can read all in one go. I found myself reading one narrative at a time and then spending time in the garden, listening to the children playing next door, needing the sounds of everyday life to surround me. I kept thinking of the people I used to know, now passed on, who must have been in similar situations but of course, never spoke to me about it.
      It is so very hard to think of loved ones in peril, more so when the peril is still, after all these years and the torrent of words, unfathomable.


  2. A timely book to read indeed Lisa and it is good to remember in the midst of all the horror that there were many decent human beings. Let’s hope today people do open their hearts, minds, and their wallets because the UN and other agencies certainly need support in the face of the biggest movement of refugees since WW2.


    • Indeed, yes, Mairi, I should have put a link to agencies for people to support, I’ll do that now.


  3. […] (2015).  I haven’t read The Last Sky, but based on its blurb and my reading of After This, (see my review) it seems to me that Nelson is drawn to the melancholy.  She writes about exile, displacement, […]


  4. […] Alice Nelson, In Arcadia, see my review of After This and The Children’s […]


  5. […] Alice Nelson, In Arcadia, see my review of After This and The Children’s […]


Please share your thoughts and join the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: