Posted by: Lisa Hill | January 8, 2017

The Choir of Gravediggers (2016), by Mel Hall

the-choir-of-gravediggersThe Choir of Gravediggers was a serendipitous discovery via Nathan Hobby who not only blogs his progress towards a monumental biography of Katharine Susannah Prichard but also writes The Annotations of Nathan Hobby.  A short story deriving from family history research, the book appealed to me because the central character is Charles Truelove, the author’s great-great grandfather who was manager of the East St Kilda Cemetery.

Now as it happens, I know this cemetery well.  Upon the death of one of the nuns at school, we would have an afternoon off to form a guard of honour for her funeral, and (as I said in my comment on Nathan’s blog) we were a sort of rent-a-crowd at the burial.  Since the nuns were mostly very old indeed, we didn’t know any of them, but I still think it’s a good thing to give a respectful send-off to these ladies who’d spent their whole life in the service of others.  But since this cemetery was established way back in 1851, it is also a very interesting cemetery and so I used to saddle up the dog  at weekends and mooch around looking at the historic graves.  (I often had to carry the dog (a dachshund) most of the way home because she only had little legs and got too tired to walk any more).


East St Kilda Cemetery (Source: Google Maps)

The most notable grave is Alfred Deakin’s. Deakin was a notable leader of the movement to federate the Australian colonies, and he was our second prime minister (1903-4, they didn’t last long in those days either).  But there are also four premiers,  Albert Jacka VC, and Ferdinand von Mueller, the botanist who set up our magnificent Botanic Gardens here in Melbourne, and who you may remember from my review of Collecting Ladies by Penny Olsen.  (You can see some of the other notables at Wikipedia). But it was mostly the long-forgotten pioneers who captured my interest, the families who lost their children in infancy, and the ones whose headstones gave a place of birth far away.  (I’ve also been known to explore the Cheltenham Pioneer Cemetery which also has many poignant headstones from the years of early settlement.  I used to give a lift to a friend visiting the doctor across the road, and the cemetery was a more congenial place to wait for her than a germ-laden waiting room).

What I did not know all those years ago at the East St Kilda Cemetery was the curious history of Mr Truelove.  Mel Hall’s short story is one of those fictions based on a true story – with the gaps filled in by the author’s imagination.  After her mother’s death, the narrator discovers some old documents in a hatbox and learns the reason why family history has been suppressed.  As the blurb says:

The Choir of Gravediggers takes us back to late nineteenth century Melbourne; a cemetery and a church, choral singing, grave-trafficking, pet incineration, a shipwreck, competitive flower arranging and one man struck by lightning.

Quite a lot to fit into only 48 pages!   I read it while waiting in the car for The Spouse to collect his mother from her aged care home for a Sunday excursion.  (The wait takes a while, because she forgets we’re coming, but she’s always very pleased to see us and we enjoy taking her out for a cup of tea and cake.)  Some of the story is amusing, but there are, fittingly, poignant episodes as well:

It was 1905, and I was seven when he disappeared.  I walked downstairs and saw the empty space on the hatstand.  Only a small space, but empty all the same, carved and set like a question mark in time.  It was just the first stage in a process of vanishing. (p.33)

It might have been easier to vanish to avoid a scandal in those days, but Truelove left enough traces for contemporary research to tell his remarkable story.


Author: Mel Hall
Title: The Choir of Gravediggers
Publisher: Ginninderra Press, 2016
ISBN: 9781760411459
Source: Personal library, purchased from Fishpond $16.90

Available from Fishpond: The Choir of Gravediggers


  1. Oh, I know that cemetery too, as my sister once lived in East St Kilda and I have a “thing” for wandering around looking at headstones! So many stories are lying in the ground or in tombs, don’t you think? I spend a lot of time exploring Brompton Cemetery here in West London, which is one of the “Magnificent Seven” and the resting place of Emily Pankhurst who has a beautiful art-deco monument adorning her grave.


    • You know, travelling with The Spouse is an absolute delight because we both like seeing the same things, but I haven’t yet been able to persuade him to do a cemetery in the UK. We did, however, make a pilgrimage to the cemetery in Vienna to see Beethoven’s grave, and we’ve done the notables in St Paul’s, so there is hope yet:)


  2. Thanks for the link, and I’m so pleased for Mel that you’ve reviewed the book! It’s actually a book and a milieu that felt so close to my Katharine Susannah Prichard research – she was living not far from St Kilda in South Yarra from 1907, and used to walk into the city with Deakin sometimes. (He knew her mother, but I’ve found some other connections too.)


    • I’m a bit tempted to take an excursion there once the weather is more benign…


Please share your thoughts and join the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: