Posted by: Lisa Hill | February 7, 2012

A Soldier’s Tale (2010), by M.K.Joseph

The temptation with this gripping  novel is to rush through it because you simply have to know how it is resolved.  The problem with that approach is that such a rich and complex novel of ideas and exquisite writing, deserves more attention.  This is a perfect book for book groups to explore, and an even better one to read and re-read, taking time to ponder the moral ambiguities that underlie the tale.

A Soldier’s Tale by M.K.Joseph (1914-1981) was first published in 1976 but has been recently reissued to great acclaim.  It’s the story of a soldier caught up in a moral dilemma not initially of his making.  It’s set in Normandy in 1944,  when the Germans were in retreat and the Allies were making their way through rural France towards Paris, liberating villages and towns as they did so.  During a lull in the fighting two young British soldiers go for a stroll, looking for some loot or a ‘nice bit of crumpet’.  They come across a young girl alone in an isolated cottage and Saul has begun his pick-up routine when suddenly the girl freezes in terror.  Three men from the French Resistance have arrived to deal with her.  She is a collaborator, they say, and not just one who slept with the enemy.  They are going to kill her.

Saul, who’s a bit of a lad and has only a rudimentary sort of moral code, reacts in a matter-of-fact kind of way.  These three are amateurs, as far as he’s concerned and he’s a battle-hardened killer who knows what he’s doing with a gun or a knife.  It doesn’t take him long to show them that they are in no position to challenge him, but they know that he has to move on with the rest of his company.  The protection he offers her is temporary at best unless he can find some other sanctuary for her.  So the tension in the novel comes from the resolution of this stand-off.  That is why you have to keep reading long into the night when you ought not to because there is work in the morning and that hateful alarm at six a.m.

But there is much more to it than that.  Saul’s mercy is tempered by opportunism and betrayal stalks the novel.   In the Foreword by Janet Hughes, she notes that Joseph, a former soldier and academic, as well as one of New Zealand’s finest poets and novelists, was interested in the moral sphere:

For the most part he is more concerned with the ethics of individual conduct than with warfare itself – with the way war sharpens dilemmas, intensifies pressures, and magnifies consequences, rather than with its physical or political violence.

The relationship that develops between Belle and her protector is complex and ambiguous.  They both have assumptions about each other that erupt into conflict.  He thinks he has entitlements; she is willing to please him but she wants to choose it, not to owe him.  A man not in the habit of reflecting on his motives and behaviour, Saul isn’t very good at expressing himself either and their communication is hampered still further by her lapses into French when her English fails her.  There are moments which will make most readers angry with both characters; there are also scenes so poignant you may weep.

It’s unforgettable.

© Lisa Hill

Author: M.K.Joseph
Title: A Soldier’s Tale
Publisher: Harper Collins (New Zealand) 2010
ISBN: 9781869508555
Source: Personal library, purchased from Fishpond, $22.68

Fishpond: A Soldier’s Tale


  1. I see we’ve both been poring over this book tonight! :)


    • Indeed yes, Tania, and what a hard review to write without giving away any spoilers!


  2. I’ve never heard of this book or author? I guess you’re reading it in your ANZLitLovers group?


    • I’d never heard of it either until it was nominated for our schedule. But Joseph has written a heap of other novels across a range of genres. Maybe this is part of a trend by publishers to make more of their beaut backlists available? Text is doing it here in Oz too, and then there are Popular Penguins…


      • Yes, it is great … I wrote about Text and Popular Penguins, et al, in a recent Monday Musings. It’s so good to see, isn’t it?


        • Well, when I think of how other countries don’t shelve their backlist and let it lapse into obscurity, it makes you wonder why it’s taken so long. It may have something to do with the shift from what’s often called ‘gentlemen’s publishing’ i.e. publishing for the love of it to ‘publishing for profit’. (That’s probably not a fair description of either, because I’m sure publishers before the era of big corporates wanted to make a profit and I’m sure that there are people who love books and writing in the era of the big corporates too, but you know what I mean). Anyway, maybe people thought there was no profit in a backlist and that the reading public was only interested in a constant stream of new books and authors?
          I love supporting our debut authors and I love discovering authors new to me, but I’m a Blytonite from way back and there are thousands of us, who will read everything written by an author that we love!


  3. Thanks for this review Lisa I remember a couple of years ago on the radio some one mention this book and like me forgot to note it down as I liked the sound of it then even more after this review will check my library see if they have got it ,all the best stu


    • I hope you can find one, Stu, it’s such a brilliant book, it deserves international recognition.


  4. Oh goodie, this sounds just like my sort of thing. I love books about dark moral dilemmas and the way people behave under all kinds of stress and unnatural conditions.

    It’s available to download on Kindle here in the UK, so that’s good, although I’m trying not to buy books until I get through some of the piles cluttering up the place here first (Ha!)

    I note there’s plenty of second hand copies too and it looks like it was turned into a movie starring Gabriel Byrne at some point…


    • A movie? Maybe I can source a copy from somewhere…it would make a fantastic film
      PS I am not taking your ‘I’m not buying any books’ comment seriously of course!


  5. […] (A Soldier’s Tale, by M.K. Joseph deals with the aftermath of collaboration for people so ordinary it can make you weep). […]


Please share your thoughts and join the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: