Posted by: Lisa Hill | September 8, 2015

The Landing (2015), by Susan Johnson

The LandingWhile I am guessing that the marketing department at Allen & Unwin have chosen this cliché cover design to appeal to a wider audience than Susan Johnson’s readership who like her literary fiction, the problem is that by focussing our attention on a (headless) woman on a pier, (#GettyImagesSearch = landing/pier (n) +woman) the image deflects from the wider meaning of the word ‘landing’.  The landings that Susan Johnson explores in this witty and intelligent novel are those that people make when they find themselves landed in places where they didn’t expect to be.  Metaphorically speaking, that is.  (I don’t think marketing departments like metaphorical much.)

After a long period of being married, Jonathon Lott has landed on the perilous rocky shore of marital separation.  He’s wealthy, good-looking, only 55, still able to attract the attention of hopefuls within and outside his age bracket.  But it’s not what he wants.  He doesn’t want to start again, he wants the ease of a comfortable old marriage.  Perhaps this contributed to Sarah’s departure… readers will make up their own minds about that.

That very ambiguity is what lifts the novel out of the predictable romance genre.  It goes nowhere near Relationships #101 because the author brings original insights to bear on the story.  It’s narrated from several points of view besides Jonathan’s, ranging across the generations with Penny Collins in the middle, sandwiched between the demands of her difficult old mother Marie and her impulsive daughter Scarlet.

‘One can never live too far away from one’s mother’ says Penny’s sister Rosemary in Perth.  Yes, the most isolated city in the world, and well away from a mother who is asked to leave one retirement home after another.  Penny has been landed with her mother and while love can be comfortably pragmatic from Rosemary’s distance of 4000km away, close up, it’s not so easy.  Especially with a mother as awful as Marie has consistently been, belittling Penny since childhood, upstaging her at every turn, mocking her ambition to be an artist and not the teacher that she has had to settle for. (See this Sensational Snippet from the novel).  That’s the trouble with parents, Johnson knows.  They can be difficult indeed, not people that you like, but the urge to protect them and care for them when they are vulnerable goes far beyond a sense of irritated duty.

In Penny’s case, she knows too little about her mother’s own painful childhood, too little about the fragility of her self-confidence.  What might have helped her understand her mother’s defensive strategies remains hidden except for unguarded moments that leak snippets of her life story to her baffled daughter.  And this ambiguity is true too.  Sometimes it’s just not possible for children to know their parents, and more so when the child is like Penny, a first generation Australian who grew up believing in the idea of home as a safe haven, a concept still foreign to many people around the world.

But Marie finds some comfort in the naiveté of her new husband Syd:

That dark night on The Sunlander, swaying, rattling, swinging round corners, they lay like children, holding hands.  ‘You are safe now,’ he said.  Although she did not believe him, she was moved by his declaration, comforted by the thought that there were still people in the world who believed that safety was a static concept and not provisional; people who did not know that the world around them, even life itself, was counterfeit.  The wall was thin, too thin even to be called a wall; everything else was the vanity of human wishes, hoping to remake that which was already done.  (p. 121)

Scarlet, struggling with the demands of parenting, finds love less romantic than she expected.  Johnson has a little fun with contemporary baby-naming practice for amongst Scarlet’s other follies she has chosen Ajax for her first born (and he turns out not to be indestructible after all) and Hippolyte for her second son. (Yes, that’s the Amazonian queen, oh! imagine the torment in secondary school when they find out, which they will because Greek myth is the foundation of a lot of digital gaming.) Scarlett running off with her mother’s contemporary, Rosanna’s husband Paul Raymond – who is also a resident in this small incestuous community – has tested Penny’s love.  A discarded wife herself, she admires Rosanna’s equanimity but can’t achieve it herself:

Rosanna was free.  Rosanna refused to hold on to her pain.  Rosanna had let everything go because forgiveness is a choice not to suffer. (p. 13)

The setting, for all its upmarket lakeside location, is a mirror reflecting the realities of life in small communities everywhere.  Everyone knows everyone, and knows everyone’s business.  There is no need for internet shaming, embarrassment lies around every corner.  Yet the homing instinct brings people back to where they belong, even when holding one’s head up high is harder to do in a place where there is nowhere to hide.

One minor character also exposes how cruel and distant small communities can be, how they can exclude the outsider who doesn’t fit their norms.  Giselle, only seven, has come to The Landing because one of her mother’s friends has offered them a temporary home after the boyfriend committed suicide.  But her nameless mother is a negligent drug addict, and while Jonathan takes a fleeting interest, Sylv who runs the only shop in the community dismisses Giselle without a thought.  ‘Poor child’ says Jonathan when Giselle leaves the shop, her wish for a Wagon Wheel ungranted.

‘Oh, she’s all right,’ said Sylv.  ‘Tough as old boots, like all kids.  They survive.’

Do they?  He saw Giselle’s small triangle of a face, her knotted hair.  (p. 69)

The Landing is a wise and thoughtful commentary on Australian contemporary life, from one of our best authors.

Author: Susan Johnson
Title: The Landing
Publisher: Allen and Unwin, 2015
ISBN: 9781760113933
Source: review copy courtesy of Allen & Unwin


Fishpond: The Landing and good bookshops everywhere



  1. I reviewed The Landing for the Age and Sydney Morning Herald. It’s interesting that you picked such different aspects of the book to comment on – can’t say what mine were because my review hasn’t been published yet. I always like hearing what other reviewers have to say.


  2. I enjoyed the novel. I think it is witty and thoughtful, and think both reviews were excellent. I know my book club would have fun in dissecting the characters. I thought the ending for all the characters was far too neat. Like you Lisa, I did worry about Giselle. I don’t think her life would turn out well.


    • Yes, a haunting little character, Giselle… it’s not a neat ending for her, that’s for sure!
      But I wonder about the others…if I imagine myself writing the next couple of chapters, are those pairings going to work out? I’m not so sure!


  3. […] For another take on this novel, please see Lisa’s review. […]


  4. […] Sunshine State: the Dreaded Family Christmas at Surfers Paradise.  Am I right in thinking that The Landing (2015) was Johnson’s most recent novel?  Is it unreasonable of me to tap my foot and pout […]


  5. […] in my defence I can say that my ‘story’ came about over a chatty lunch with the author Susan Johnson, and I had no intention of suggesting that she (or anyone else) should write it.  She was the one […]


Please share your thoughts and join the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: